[tdwg-ncd] RE: NCD version 0.50 mappings
m.doering at BGBM.org
Thu Mar 15 16:11:10 CET 2007
I dont think we have to be afraid of too many fields, especially due to additional language attributes.
It's a matter of the editor frontend rather than the data standard. The editor should surely be easy to use and focus on the important things first, leaving secondary information for "expert".
From: tdwg-ncd-bounces at lists.tdwg.org on behalf of Thomson, Neil
Sent: Wed 3/14/2007 10:58 AM
To: bmathe at amnh.org
Cc: tdwg-ncd at lists.tdwg.org
Subject: [tdwg-ncd] RE: NCD version 0.50 mappings
Many thanks for this - I've been out of the Museum for a few days and will take a look as soon as I can. Thanks also to Ricardo for sorting the bounce - I attach the original file here for the rest of the group to see, as intended.
From: Barbara Mathe [mailto:bmathe at amnh.org]
Sent: 13 March 2007 03:35
To: Neil Thomson
Cc: Barbara Mathe; tdwg-ncd at lists.tdwg.org
Subject: Re: NCD version 0.50 mappings
Forgive me but I am simply attaching the excel file to this e-mail since it is late and I must catch a plane early tomorrow AM. I have found this particularly difficult, in part for reasons I will describe below.
That said, the document is now rainbow colored--for better or worse--at least it's cheerful. I have highlighted all changes from the earlier mapping (basically the cumulative changes from 0.34 to 0.50 in yellow.
Someone should double check to make sure that I included all the fields.
I believe I have but I could use some copyediting here. I have also noted any questions that I have in green. You will notice a few questions about certain fields, e.g. McGinley, now described as such, should not (I think) any longer need a source specified. I also added a copy edit or two myself. Neil, in particular, I think you should have a good look.
However, I am still concerned about two things.
1. My basic lack of experience with EAD. This must be reviewed by someone facile with this standard as opposed to me who must constantly consult (and interpret) the documentation. This mapping is very important and I've said this before but I just am not confident of my expertise here. I believe that someone with such expertise could answer the questions, I have noted but I have to say that I'm still uncertain about how to handle language attributes, in particular. The mapping is close but this is something that should be perfect.
2. Speaking of the language attributes, I am struck at the number of fields that now (since 0.34) specify a language attibute and although I realize these are not required, after battling with them, I fear, once again, at the complexity of the schema. I think we will have to look at interface issues down the road, at least for participants who will be directly entering data rather than mapping it from another source. We will need a NCD "simple" to encourage contributions. Right now, with attributes, there are 146 fields!
NB: The DC mappings in column D and E have been carried over but are hidden. There may be some updating needed there as well from 0.34 to 0.50 (rows highlighted in yellow!)
I'm out of town for the rest of the week but will be checking e-mail.
Looking for any and all comments.
> Barbara Mathé
> Museum Archivist and Head of Library Special Collections American
> Museum of Natural History Library Central Park West @ 79 Street New
> York, NY
> phone: 212 769-5419
> fax: 212 769-5009
> -----Original Message-----
> From: tdwg-ncd-bounces at lists.tdwg.org
> [mailto:tdwg-ncd-bounces at lists.tdwg.org] On Behalf Of Markus Döring
> Sent: Tuesday, February 27, 2007 8:47 AM
> To: Neil Thomson
> Cc: tdwg-ncd at lists.tdwg.org
> Subject: Re: [tdwg-ncd] NCD version 0.50
> I have added v0.50 to the tdwg resource directory.
> The schema resource is now available at:
> If you want to refer to the schema, please use this URL:
> The latest development version of NCD is also update and available at
> best wishes
> On Feb 27, 2007, at 10:04 AM, Neil Thomson wrote:
>> Dear all,
>> Please find attached version 0.50 of NCD. The following changes from
>> v0.40 have been made:
>> Version 0.40 to 0.50 - (February 2007)
>> Ensured all elements with a language attribute are repeatable
>> (if not already)
>> - AgentRole
>> - Note (in Agents)
>> - CollectionName
>> - Abstract
>> - DescriptionForSpecialists
>> - Citation
>> - Notes (in Descriptive Group)
>> - AccessRestrictions
>> - UsageRestrictions
>> - CustodialHistory
>> - InstitutionName
>> - SubunitName
>> - InstitutionalContactPost
>> - Town
>> - Region
>> - CountryName
>> - ExpeditionName
>> Removed language attribute from <PostalAddressText> - assume
>> native language
>> Added <PhysicalAddressText> to cater for P.O.Boxes to
>> Institution Group
>> Added <SubUnitName> to Institution Group
>> I hope that no further changes will be required until we get more
>> operational experience of working with NCD, but do please let me know
>> as soon as possible if there is anything glaringly wrong or missing.
>> I also hope that these changes should not have much of an impact on
>> any implementations based on the previous version.
>> The intention is that this version remains as is for some time, so
>> that the tasks we undertake this year can be based on a stable
>> version of the standard. This includes the production of the NCD
>> Toolkit by NLBIF, the conversion to RDF by Markus and the
>> documentation and mappings being coordinated by Connie. A complete
>> list of deliverables for the year is (or will be shortly) on the wikis.
>> I will be placing the updated file, with text-based and image-based
>> derivations, on the NCD Website and on the RAVNS Basecamp in due
>> For those of you that are aiming to attend the NCD 2007 Workshop, the
>> dates are almost confirmed as June 18th and 19th, with ETI in
>> Amsterdam as the host institution. More information on this later.
>> With all best wishes,
>> Neil Thomson
>> Head of Data & Digital Systems
>> The Natural History Museum, Cromwell Road, London SW7 5BD
>> Tel: +44 (0)20 7942 5294,
>> Fax: +44 (0)20 7942 5559,
>> Email: n.thomson at nhm.ac.uk
>> tdwg-ncd mailing list
>> tdwg-ncd at lists.tdwg.org
> tdwg-ncd mailing list
> tdwg-ncd at lists.tdwg.org
Museum Archivist and Head of Library Special Collections American Museum of Natural History Central Park West at 79 Street New York, NY 10024
Phone: 212 769-5419
Fax: 212 769-5009
More information about the tdwg-content